Decaying sterile neutrino can mimic oscillation signals at neutrino experiments. We revisit this possibility as a solution to the MiniBooNE and LSND puzzles in view of new data from MicroBooNE. Using MicroBooNE's search for an excess of in the Booster beam, we derive new limits in the parameter space of models where the sterile neutrino decays via mixing or higher-dimensional operators. In order to contextualize these limits, we also provide a comprehensive fit to the MiniBooNE neutrino and antineutrino data, including appearance and disappearance channels. We find that MicroBooNE excludes a large portion of the MiniBooNE-preferred parameter space at more than 95% C.L.